Cover Image

On the Boate Kiss Fire and the Brazilian Safety Legislation - What we can learn

Henrique Costa Braga, Gray Farias Moita

Abstract


Brazil was recently the scenario of a great tragedy in the fire at Kiss nightclub, where 242 people were killed. The starting point of the fire was the use of a pyrotechnic device over an acoustic coating made of polyurethane foam. The causalities were caused mainly by asphyxia and inhalation of toxic gases in a very fast smoke expansion. However, several additional causes contributed to the amount of damage and human losses. The accident investigations emphasized the necessity to discuss details in the applicable Brazilian legislation. In this work, the tragedy of Kiss nightclub is presented and the some of their mainly aspects discussed. The Brazilian standard (ABNT NBR 9077) to determine the dimension of emergency exits is also presented. Then, a computational simulation of evacuation process in an environment externally similar to Kiss nightclub with different width exits and populations is performed using the software Fuga. It was found that, in spite of the configurations of Kiss nightclub have had a fundamental role in tragedy, the current Brazilian standard was not appropriate for the design of such environment and should not have been used. Moreover, clear and more rigorous standards also need to be further discussed, particularly for panic situations. At the end, some considerations are made in order to improve the standards about the dimensioning of emergency exits.

Keywords


Boate Kiss; Kiss nightclub; safety legislation; fire; evacuation; nightclub; Brazil; emergency exit; smoke; ABNT NBR 9077

Full Text:

PDF

References


Albuquerque, I.M., Trevisan, M.E., Pasqualoto, A.S., Prado, A.L.C., Pereira, M.B., Badaró, A.F.V.: Physical therapy performance in the rehabilitation of survivors of the Kiss nightclub tragedy: an experience report. Fisioterapia em Movimento 28(4), 649-655 (2015). doi:10.1590/0103-5150.028.004.AO01

Knauss, P.A.: The city as feeling: history and memory of an event in contemporary society: the fire at the Gran Circus Norte-Americano in Niterói. [in portuguese]. Revista Brasileira de História 27(53), 25-54 (2007). doi:10.1590/S0102-01882007000100003

Duval, R.F.: NFPA Case Study: nightclub fires. NFPA (2006)

Strick, J.: Development of Safety Measures for Nightclubs. Lund University (2014). URL http://lup.lub.lu.se/luur/download?func=downloadFile&recordOId=4522713&fileOId=4522718

Grosshandler, W., Bryner, N., Madrzykowski, D., Kuntz, K.: Report of the Technical Investigation of The Station Nightclub Fire. NIST (2005). URL http://www.nist.gov/customcf/get_pdf.cfm?pub_id=100988

Galea, E.R., Wang, Z., Veeraswamy, A., Jia, F., Lawrence, P.J., Ewer, J.: Coupled fire/evacuation analysis of The Station Nightclub fire. Fire Safety Science 9, 465-476 (2008). doi:10.3801/IAFSS.FSS.9-465

Moncada, J.A.: The kiss of death. [in portuguese]. NFPA Journal Latinoamericano 15(2), 18-24 (2013). URL http://www.nfpajla.org/pt/arquivos/lugares-de-reunioes-publicas-discotecas/993-el-beso-de-la-muerte

Atiyed, B.: Brazilian Kiss nightclub disaster. Annals of Burns and Fire Disasters 26(1), 3-4 (2013). URL http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3741004/pdf/Ann-Burns-and-Fire-Disasters-26-3.pdf

Marques, G.F.: The Kiss tragedy. [in portuguese], (video). In: Seminário de Seguranca Contra Incendio e Panico. CBMMG (2014)

Sanchonete, C.R.S., Garcia, A.D.: Police comissioner Marcelo Arigony's profile on Facebook: the circulation of meanings on the fire at nightclub Kiss, in Santa Maria (RS). [in portuguese]. Dispositiva 2(2), 103-118 (2014). URL http://periodicos.pucminas.br/index.php/dispositiva/article/view/7629

Souza, D.V., Machado, R.F., Montes, R.G.E., Souza, I.C.: Fire at the Boate Kiss: analysis of the ethical conduct of civil engineers [in portuguese]. Revista JurisFIB 6, 441-449 (2013). URL http://www.revistajurisfib.com.br/artigos/1395811460.pdf

Antonio, A.C.P., Castro, P.S., Freire, L.O.: Smoke inhalation injury during enclosed-space fires: an update. Jornal Brasileiro de Pneumologia 39(3), 373-381 (2013). doi:10.1590/S1806-37132013000300016

Bassi, E., Miranda, L.C., Tierno, F.G.M.M., Ferreira, C.B., Cadamouro, F.M., Damasceno, M.C.T., Malbouisson, L.M.S.: Assistance of inhalation injury caused by fire in confined spaces: what we learned from the tragedy at Santa Maria. Revista Brasileira de Terapia Intensiva 26(4), 421-429 (2014). doi:10.5935/0103-507X.20140065

Arigony, M.M., Meinerz, S.L., Vianna, M.R., Zanella, G.G., Souza, L.: Final Report – Police Investigation No 94/2013/150501. Santa Maria: First Police Department of Santa Maria - RS. [in portuguese] (2013)

Meinerz, S.L., Souza, L.S.: Police Inquiry – Report No 001/2013. 3a DPR - RS. [in portuguese] (2014)

Luiz, M.: Two years later, see 24 mistakes that contributed to the Kiss tragedy [in portuguese]. G1 RS (2015). URL http://g1.globo.com/rs/rio-grande-do-sul/noticia/2015/01/dois-anos-depois-veja-24-erros-que-contribuiram-para-tragedia-na-kiss.html

Santucci, J.: Fire at Boate Kiss: a preventable tragedy? [in portuguese]. Conselho em Revista 9(95), 23-27 (2013)

Gragnani, A., Oliveira, A.F., Boro, D., Pham, T., Ferreira, L.M.: Response and legislative changes after the Kiss nightclub tragedy in Santa Maria/RS/Brazil: Learning from a large-scale burn disaster. Burns 43(2), 343-349 (2016). doi:10.1016/i.burns.2016.08.010

ABNT: ABNT NBR 9077:2001 - Buildings - Emergency Exits - Procedure. Associacao Brasileira de Normas Técnicas. [in portuguese] (2001)

Goldstone, R., Roberts, M.E.: Self-organized trail systems in groups of human. Complexity 11(8), 43-50 (2006). doi:10.1002/cplx.20135

Schadschneider, A., Klingsch, W., Klüpfel, H., Kretz, T., Rogsch, C., Seyfried, A.: Evacuation dynamics: Empirical results, modeling and applications. In: Encyclopedia of Complexity and Systems Science, pp. 3142-3176 (2009). doi:10.1007/978-0-387-30440-3_187

Helbing, D., Johansson, A.: Pedestrian, crowd and evacuation dynamics. In: Encyclopedia of Complexity and Systems Science, pp. 6476-6495 (2009). doi:10.1007/978-1-4419-7695-6_37

Pelechano, N., Allbeck, J., Badler, N.: Virtual Crowds: methods, simulation, and control. Morgan & Claypool (2008). doi:10.2200/S00123ED1V01Y200808CGR008

Bakar, J.A.A., Mat, R.C., Aziz, A.A., Jasri, N.A.N., Yusof, M.F.: Designing agent-based modeling in dynamic crowd simulation for stressful environment. Journal of Telecommunication, Electronic and Computer Engineering 8(10), 151-156 (2016)

Rogsch, C., Klingsch, W., Seyfried, A., Weigel, H.: Prediction accuracy of evacuation times for high-rise buildings and simple geometries by using different software-tools. In: Traffic and Granular Flow 2007, pp. 395-400. Springer (2009). doi:10.1007/978-3-540-77074-9_42

Curtis, S., Best, A., Manocha, D.: Menge: a modular framework for simulating crowd movement. Collective Dynamics 1(A1), 1-49 (2016). doi:10.17815/CD.2016.1

Silva, V.M., Scholl, M.V., Correa, B.A., Adamatti, D.F., Gomes, S.C.P.: Evacuation of the Kiss nightclub: a multiagent simulation of the real scenario in relation to the ideal [in portuguese]. In: 14o Conferencia Ibero Americana WWW/Internet, p. 5 (2016)

Kinateder, M.T., Kuligowski, E.D., Reneke, P.A., Peacock, R.D.: Risk perception in fire evacuation behavior revisited: definitions, related concepts, and empirical evidence. Fire Science Reviews 4(1), 1-26 (2015). doi:10.1186/s40038-014-0005-z

Silva, L.C.P., Wengrover, C., Saldanha, M., Brentano, T., Rodrigues, E.E.C.: Analysis of the sinister at Boate Kiss in Santa Maria, RS. CREA-RS. [in portuguese] (2013)

Trevisan, M., Jesus, I.J.: Civil action for conviction for acts of administrative impropriety. Santa Maria: Prosecutors of Justice of Santa Maria. [in portuguese] (2013)

Seivers, I., Templaton, A., Köster, G., Drury, J., Philippides, A.: Humans do not always act selfishly: social identity and helping in emergency evacuation simulation. Transportation Research Procedia 2, 585-593 (2014). doi:10.1016/j.trpro.2014.09.099

ABNT: Brazilian Standardization History. Associacao Brasileira de Normas Técnicas. [in portuguese] (2011). URL http://www.abnt.org.br/images/pdf/historia-abnt.pdf

Bukowski, R.W.: Emergency Egress from Buildings. Part 1: History and Current Regulations for Egress System Design. NIST Technical Note 1623. NIST (2009). URL http://fire.nist.gov/bfrlpubs/fire09/PDF/f09017.pdf

Gill, A.A., Negrisolo, W., Oliveira, S.A.: Learning from the big fires. In: The Safety Against Fire in Brazil. [in portuguese], pp. 19-33. Projeto Editora (2008). doi:10.13140/2.1.1133.5680

Faillace, R.R.: Stairs and Emergency Exits. [in portuguese]. Sagra (1991)

Pan, X., Han, C.S., Dauber, K., Law, K.H.: A multi-agent based framework for the simulation of human and social behaviors during emergency evacuations. AI & Society 22(2), 113-132 (2007). doi:10.1007/s00146-007-0126-1

Braga, H.C., Moita, G.F.: Modeling with fuzzy logic the dynamic of people flow during the evacuation of constructed environments dimensioned according to the brazilian legislation. In: 11th World Congress on Computational Mechanics - WCCM, pp. 6458-6467 (2014)

Cirillo, E.N.M., Muntean, A.: Dynamics of pedestrian in regions with no visibility - a lattice model without exclusion. Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Application 392(17), 3578-3588 (2013). doi:10.1016/j.physa.2013.04.029

Averill, J.D., Mileti, D., Peacock, R., Kuligowski, E., Groner, N., Proulx, G., Reneke, P., Nelson, H.: Federal investigation on the evacuation of the World Trade Center on September 11, 2001. In: Pedestrian and Evacuation Dynamics 2005, pp. 1-12 (2005). doi:10.1007/978-3-540-47064-9_1

Braga, H.C., Moita, G.F., Almeida, P.E.M.: Can the average distance to be covered to the nearest exit be used as a complementary safety parameter in a building? In: Pedestrian and Evacuation Dynamics 2016, pp. 408-412 (2016)

Low, D.J.: Statistical physics: following the crowd. Nature 407, 465-466 (2000). doi:10.1038/35035192

Aik, L.E.: Exit-selection behaviors during a classroom evacuation. International Journal of Physical Sciences 6(13), 3218-3231 (2011)

Seyfried, A., Passons, O., Steffen, B., Boltes, M., Rupprecht, T., Klingsch, W.: New insights into pedestrian flow through bottlenecks. Transportation Science 43(3), 395-406 (2009). doi:10.1287/trsc.1090.0263

Carlo, U.: The safety against fire in Brazil. In: The Safety Against Fire in Brazil. [in portuguese], pp. 9-17. Projeto Editora (2008). doi:10.13140/2.1.1133.5680

Brentano, T.: Emergency exits. In: The Protection Against Fire in Buildings Design. [in portuguese], pp. 159-282. Telmo Brentano (2010)

Silva, V.P., Pannoni, F.D., Ono, R.: The training of professionals in the area of fire safety. In: The Safety Against Fire in Brazil. [in portuguese], pp. 429-430. Projeto Editora (2008). doi:10.13140/2.1.1133.5680

Vilar, E., Rebelo, F., Noriega, P., Duarte, E., Mayhorn, C.B.: Effects of competing environmental variables and signage on route-choices in simulated everyday and emergency wayfinding situations. Ergonomics 57(4), 511-524 (2014). doi:10.1080/00140139.2014.895054

Dachner, G.C., Kinateder, M.: Effects of visual information on decision making during way-finding in emergency and non-emergency situations. In: Pedestrian and Evacuation Dynamics 2016, pp. 185-189 (2016)

Haghani, M., Sarvi, M., Shahhoseini, Z., Boltes, M.: How simple hypothetical-choice experiments can be utilized to learn humans´ navigational escape decisions in emergencies. PLos ONE 11(11), 1-24 (2016). doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0166908




DOI: http://dx.doi.org/10.17815/CD.2017.12

Copyright (c) 2017 Henrique Costa Braga, Gray Farias Moita

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.